Blacksmith vs. Compliance Scorecard: Practical Comparison

Both Blacksmith and Compliance Scorecard support MSPs in navigating regulatory compliance, minimizing risk, and operationalizing their compliance services. 

Shared Strengths

  • Both platforms are purpose-built for MSPs, enabling efficient compliance management and policy automation.

  • Each provides multi-tenant capability, central policy management, audit tracking, asset governance, and risk register functionality.

  • Compliance documentation is streamlined, with customizable templates and easy content deployment.

     

  • Fast-track cyber insurance eligibility across dozens of carriers via platform-built integrations.
blacksmith compliance scorecard compare better

Feature Comparison

Where Blacksmith Adds Value

  • Built by Compliance Experts: While both platforms are built for MSPs, Blacksmith was created by experts in the compliance and vCISO space, not a former MSP. This means the combined experience and expertise of a team of compliance professionals is in the product’s DNA, not an add-on.
  • Developed In-House: Blacksmith has been, and continues to be, developed entirely in-house by the company founders. Because Blacksmith’s development is not outsourced in any respect, the developers have immense control and flexibility when it comes to tailoring the product to MSP needs.
  • Clear Compliance Roadmap: Blacksmith gives MSPs an actionable, prioritized, easy-to-understand compliance roadmap with proprietary guardrails rather than a blank canvas, dramatically reducing the guesswork and hassle involved in compliance setup.
  • Automated, Expert-Written Policies: Blacksmith gives you cross-mapped, expert-authored policies that can be tailored for each client’s environment quickly and reliably — making onboarding and ongoing management a breeze.
  • Holistic Approach: With Blacksmith’s approach to incident response planning, risk assessments, and TPRM, our platform emphasizes meaningful security improvement and ongoing risk conversation rather than just documentation, ensuring practical and ongoing protection for clients.

Where Compliance Scorecard Excels

  • GaaS Program Focus: Compliance Scorecard offers dedicated Governance-as-a-Service scorecards for policy, risk, asset, assessments, and insurance, with strong support for authorization and adoption phases.

     

  • Training Available: A 12-week training program is available for an additional charge for those who need help learning the software.

     

  • vCISO Support: Offers access to vCISOs that can be outsourced for an additional cost. 

Conclusion

Both solutions deliver proven value for MSPs handling compliance across many clients. Blacksmith stands out for providing a practical, guided compliance process, minimizing overhead, and helping MSPs ramp up their offerings efficiently, while Compliance Scorecard emphasizes granular scorecard-based governance, policy documentation, and sector-specific compliance packs. When comparing these solutions, it’s important to remember that Blacksmith includes all policies for a single flat rate, while Compliance Scorecard charges for additional policy packs.

Check Out Our Compliance Podcast on Spotify!